Alocasia Ninja Vs Black Velvet -Is Ninja A Sub Variant of Black Velvet?

Alocasia Ninja and Black Velvel seem to be like the same plant in the white eye. But besides sharing the same grounds on many parameters, there are some differences as well.

So, what are the differences between Alocasia Ninja and Alocasia Black Velvet? Alocasia Ninja has bright green leaves with silver-white veins. Black Velvet has deep velvety black leaves with silver veins. Anyway, there are some debates ongoing that the Ninjas are just a sub-variant of the Black velvet.

In this detailed analysis, I will delve into the key features of both the Alocasia Ninja and the Black Velvet. I’ll try to clear out your dilemma about these plants. Just keep on reading!

Start the Debate of Alocasia Ninja Vs Black Velvet

I will discuss everything in detail but before that, the table will give you an overview. Here’s a simple comparison table between Alocasia Ninja and Alocasia Black Velvet:

Aspect	Alocasia Ninja	Alocasia Black Velvet
Leaf Color	Bright green with silver-white veins	Deep velvety black with silver veins
Leaf Texture	Smooth	Velvety
Plant Size	Compact	Compact
Light Requirements	Bright indirect light	Bright indirect light
Watering Needs	Moderate	Moderate to high
Growth Rate	Moderate	Moderate
Hardiness Zone	10-12	10-12
Pet-Friendly	Non-toxic	Non-toxic

I’ve already said, they’re familiar to many perspectives. Now the picture is quite clear to you, right? Now, what exactly are the differences? The are a few differences that set them apart from each other. I’ll have an in-depth view of that now. Keep on reading.

4 Core Differences Between Alocasia Ninja And Black Velvet

The most crucial part of the article. Give it a thorough read. I’ll try to find out the root differences between these indoor plants.

1. Leaf Color and Texture

The most noticeable difference that I find between the two plants lies in their leaf color and texture. Alocasia Ninja showcases bright green leaves with contrasting silver-white veins, creating a captivating visual appeal.

On the other hand, Alocasia Black Velvet boasts stunning deep velvety black leaves adorned with striking silver veins. This unique black coloration sets it apart from many other plants and adds an element of mystery to any space. But it’s not too available here and there. Why? Is Black Velvet rare? I’ll say yes. This plant is kind of a rare variant of Alocasia.

If you’re a fan of colorful stuff, the Alocasia Ninja is for you. If you’re in love with the classic black-and-white appearance, Black Velvet awaits!

Read About: Alocasia Melo Vs Maharani

2. Plant Size and Form

While both Alocasias are known for their compact growth, they slightly differ in their overall size and form. Alocasia Ninja typically reaches a height of around 1 to 2 feet (30 to 60 cm) and maintains a more upright, compact habit.

On the contrary, Alocasia Black Velvet can grow slightly taller, reaching up to 2.5 feet (75 cm), and may develop a bushier appearance with more extensive foliage.

Read More: Alocasia Amazonica vs Polly

3. Leaf Shape

Another noticeable difference lies in the leaf shape. Alocasia Ninja’s leaves are heart-shaped with a pointy apex, contributing to its elegance. In contrast, Alocasia Black Velvet‘s leaves are arrow-shaped, creating a more elongated and pointed appearance.

4. Leaf Texture

The texture of the leaves is distinct between the two varieties. Alocasia Ninja features smooth and glossy leaves, adding to its charm. On the other hand, Alocasia Black Velvet lives up to its name, offering a velvety touch to its dark leaves, further enhancing its allure.

Read More: Colocasia Vs Alocasia

Why Alocasia Ninja And Black Velvets are Called Almost Identical?

Well, let’s start with the expert’s opinion and research. At first glance, the Alocasia ‘Black Velvet Ninja’ and Alocasia ‘Black Velvet’ look almost identical. They both have stunning black leaves that look like they’ve been painted.

However, some say these tiny differences disappear as the plants mature. This has sparked debate – is the Ninja a real new cultivar or just a minor variation of Black Velvet?

Haha, feeling dilemmatic? Let’s dig a little more into this. Have a look at the similarities shortly.

1. Light Requirements

Both Alocasia Ninja and Alocasia Black Velvet thrive in bright indirect light. Direct sunlight can scorch their leaves, so placing them near a window with filtered sunlight or in a well-lit room is ideal.

2. Watering Needs

Similar watering habits apply to both plants. They prefer consistently moist soil but not waterlogged conditions. Allow the top layer of soil to dry slightly before watering again to prevent root rot.

3. Temperature and Humidity

As tropical plants, both Alocasias prefer warm temperatures ranging from 65°F to 80°F (18°C to 27°C). They also appreciate high humidity levels, so misting their leaves or using a humidifier can promote their well-being.

4. Propagation

Both Alocasia Ninja and Alocasia Black Velvet can be propagated through division or by separating offsets from the parent plant. This allows gardeners to expand their collection or share these stunning plants with others.

Let’s Try to Find A Suitable Match

We’ll try to make the decision based on our preference always. As for indoor plants, I’ve listed a few preferences that might help you make your decision. Let’s take a look!

Alocasia Ninja May Be A Good Choice If You

1. Prefer plants with bright green leaves and silver-white veins.
2. Have limited space in your house garden or indoor area, as Alocasia Ninja typically maintains a more compact size.
3. Have a space that receives bright indirect light, as Alocasia Ninja thrives in well-lit environments.
4. Are comfortable with maintaining moderate watering and humidity levels.

Alocasia Black Velvet May Be A Good Choice If You

1. Are attracted to plants with deep velvety black leaves and silver veins, which offer a unique and striking appearance.
2. Have slightly more space available, as Alocasia Black Velvet can grow slightly taller and develop a bushier appearance.
3. Space receives bright indirect light, as Alocasia Black Velvet also prefers well-lit environments.
4. Are comfortable with providing moderate to high levels of humidity, as this plant appreciates higher humidity levels.

For these two plants, there are no specific recommendations as they look the same. There are arguments that they’re the same variants and even the few differences disappear while the Ninja variants are aging.

Conclusion

Alocasia Ninja and Alocasia Black Velvet are striking plants with unique characteristics that appeal to different aesthetics. Alocasia Ninja captivates with its bright green leaves and silver-white veins, while Alocasia Black Velvet adds a touch of mystery with its velvety black foliage and silver veins.

Both plants share similarities in their care requirements, making them suitable for indoor spaces with proper lighting and humidity. So, the choice between the two will depend on your preference for leaf color, texture, and the specific ambiance you wish to create in your house garden or indoor space. 

I hope you will take the best decision for your indoor garden. If my discussion helps you a little, then that will be my gain. That was all for today. Thanks for reading my blog.